You clean out your closet, fill a bag with old clothes, and drop it off at a donation bin. It feels good — generous, responsible, maybe even sustainable. But have you ever wondered what actually happens to those clothes after they leave your hands?
The truth is, only a small fraction of donated clothes end up helping someone locally. The rest? They enter a tangled global system that few people understand — and even fewer talk about.
The Feel-Good Illusion
Donation bins are everywhere — grocery store parking lots, school fundraisers, even fast fashion brand storefronts. The idea is simple: instead of throwing your clothes away, donate them. Someone else will use them. Everybody wins.
But here’s the uncomfortable truth: most of what we donate doesn’t end up in anyone’s closet. In fact, some of it never even makes it onto a thrift store rack.
The Thrift Store Bottleneck
Charity shops and secondhand stores receive far more clothing than they can ever sell. Only around 10% to 20% of donations are sold domestically. The rest? Sorted, packed, and shipped overseas — often to countries in Africa, Southeast Asia, and Latin America.
Why? Because the volume of donated clothes in the U.S., UK, and Europe far exceeds local demand. We’re discarding clothing faster than anyone can wear it.
The Global Secondhand Economy
What doesn’t sell locally enters the global secondhand trade — a multi-billion-dollar industry. In countries like Ghana, Kenya, and Chile, bales of used clothing arrive by the ton, often with little regulation or oversight.
Some of these clothes are resold in open-air markets and provide jobs. But many are unwearable — ripped, stained, or cheap synthetic garments that deteriorate quickly. In Accra, Ghana’s capital, mountains of unwanted Western clothing pile up on beaches and clog drainage systems. In Chile’s Atacama Desert, literal tons of cast-off fashion sit in textile landfills, leaching dyes and synthetics into the soil.
Our donations, meant as good deeds, are often just exported waste.
The Problem With “Wishcycling” Your Wardrobe
We want to believe that giving away old clothes is automatically good — that someone, somewhere will benefit. But without questioning the system, we’re just passing the problem along.
Donating isn’t bad. But doing it without thought is. Fast fashion has made it so easy to buy (and discard) that donation feels like a solution — when it’s often a detour on the way to the landfill.
So, What Should You Do Instead?
Here are better ways to think about clearing out your closet:
1. Don’t buy as much in the first place
The most sustainable garment is the one already in your closet.
2. Rehome intentionally
If clothes are in good condition, try local Buy Nothing groups, clothing swaps, shelters, or direct community outreach.
3. Repair, repurpose, or recycle responsibly
Can the item be mended or transformed? Some natural fiber clothing can also be composted. For recycling, research textile-specific drop-offs or mail-in programs.
4. Be honest about the condition
If it’s stained, torn, or worn-out, it’s likely not going to be reused — and thrift stores will toss it. Don’t make them the landfill.
5. Shift your mindset from discard to ownership
Before buying something new, ask: will I still wear this in a year? In five? The more intentional we are at the start, the less we have to “get rid of” later.
Final Thoughts: Donating Doesn’t Erase Overconsumption
Giving feels good. But we can’t donate our way out of the fashion waste crisis. True sustainability starts earlier — with how we shop, how we wear, and how we value what we already have.
So next time you fill a donation bag, pause for a moment. Where will these clothes really go? And could the most powerful action be not giving them away — but cherishing them longer?
Reader Interactions