When American Eagle launched its fall campaign starring Sydney Sweeney, the message seemed simple on the surface: “Great jeans.” But beneath that denim pun was something deeper — and much more disturbing.
The tagline “Sydney Sweeney has great genes” wasn’t just tone-deaf. It was a mirror held up to a much bigger problem: how beauty, identity, and whiteness are often leveraged by brands without any sense of responsibility. And the excuses that followed — from both the brand and the face of the campaign — made it worse.
This post isn’t about piling on. It’s about holding space for truth, accountability, and change — because this isn’t just about a pair of jeans. It’s about how messaging shapes our values, how culture influences action, and how individuals — not just brands — must be responsible for the impact they create.
Why the Ad Is Harmful — and Not Just Cringeworthy
Let’s call it what it is: this campaign was layered with problematic symbolism. A blonde, blue-eyed woman is held up as the face of “great genes,” paired with the kind of messaging that flirts with eugenics-era language — “passed down through generations,” “my jeans are blue,” and other double-meanings that are impossible to ignore in context.
In a world still reckoning with white supremacy, the legacy of slavery, and global colonization, presenting whiteness as the visual and genetic ideal is not harmless. It’s coded. It’s cultural. It’s exclusionary.
Marketing that centers Eurocentric beauty standards and calls it “genetic greatness” isn’t clever — it’s dangerous. These messages don’t land in a vacuum. They land in a society where race still dictates opportunity, safety, and visibility.
“It’s Just Jeans” Isn’t Good Enough
American Eagle’s response was, essentially: relax, it’s a pun. But creating controversy for profit, fun, or visibility isn’t edgy — it’s harmful. Even if it gets clicks, someone always pays the price.
This kind of gaslighting — pretending the ad was only about denim while ignoring its implications — is exactly how brands avoid change. They deflect instead of reflect. They profit off the buzz and move on.
But for people who have never been seen as the face of “great genes,” this isn’t just about a campaign. It’s a reminder of how power and privilege still dominate what’s considered beautiful, valuable, and marketable.
Sydney Sweeney Is Not a Bystander
Let’s be clear: Sydney Sweeney is not a passive participant here. She is a well-known actress with agency, wealth, and a massive platform. When someone in her position signs onto a campaign, they bring their voice, their influence, and their responsibility with them.
Sweeney’s reported responses — suggesting she didn’t fully understand the campaign or did it for the paycheck — may explain the decision, but they don’t excuse the impact.
Ignorance isn’t neutral when you’re the face of a global brand. Not asking questions is a choice. And when your image is used to promote a message with genetic undertones and racial overtones, you don’t get to say, “I didn’t know.” You are accountable — not just because of who you are, but because of what you represent.
Brands Are Made of People — And People Make Choices
You can blame the brand. You should blame the brand. But here’s the harder truth: brands are made of people. People approve the concepts. People write the copy. People sign the contracts. And people cash the checks.
Accountability doesn’t stop at the logo. It begins with individuals. And when those individuals benefit from systemic privilege — whether it’s whiteness, beauty standards, or wealth — their choices carry even more weight.
Would This Ad Have Happened With a Black or Brown Model?
Ask yourself: would this ad — with its genetic messaging and aesthetic — have been greenlit if the model were Black or Brown? Would it have been celebrated? Or would it have been dissected, ridiculed, or erased entirely?
Let’s stop pretending that this kind of campaign would play the same across racial lines. Because it wouldn’t. Because it doesn’t. And that is the point.
Genes Don’t Make You Better — They Make You Human
If this campaign is about genes, here’s some science:
Every human alive today shares a common ancestor from Africa. The mitochondrial DNA that runs through your body — yes, even Sydney Sweeney’s — can be traced back to Black ancestry. Our genes, all of them, began in Africa. The genetic blueprint of modern humanity is not white. It’s Black.
So if you’re going to talk about “great genes,” start with that truth. Not an aesthetic built on exclusion. Not an ideal born from colonial beauty standards. And definitely not a campaign that glamorizes heritage while ignoring history.
You’re shaming people for their genes? The very DNA we all share? Let’s get real: no one’s genetics are superior — but pretending some are marketable while others are disposable is what keeps injustice alive.
Why Conscious Culture Matters
UberArtisan was built to champion better choices. Yes, in what we buy — but also in how we live, how we create, how we communicate.
This moment is about more than an ad. It’s about the values we endorse when we let things like this slide. When we dismiss it as “just fashion.” When we excuse individuals for profiting from exclusion.
Sustainability is not just about the Earth. It’s about people. It’s about justice. It’s about not letting marketing become a tool for harm, even if it’s dressed up in denim.
Racism, Poverty, and Pollution Are Interconnected
We cannot separate climate justice from racial justice. The communities most impacted by environmental degradation are often the same ones excluded from economic opportunity — and the same ones erased in media and marketing.
When messages like this reinforce who’s valued and who’s invisible, they contribute to the systems that cause poverty, and in turn, pollution. It’s all connected. The ripple effects are real — from air quality to access to clean water, from wage gaps to waste dumps.
To fight for the planet is to fight for dignity. To call out racism is to call in sustainability.
This Isn’t About Hate — It’s About Truth
This post isn’t a hit piece. It’s a truth piece.
Truth about who gets to represent “greatness.”
Truth about how privilege still distorts the message.
Truth about why conscious culture must be intentional, not accidental.
If you’re a creator, influencer, or brand: your choices matter. And if you’ve made mistakes — own them. Reflect. Listen. Do better.
Because being a conscious brand doesn’t mean being perfect. It means being aware. And being willing to change when it matters most.
Reader Interactions