Remember when ESG was the darling of the financial world? Suddenly every fund had a green label, every CEO had a sustainability pledge, and Wall Street pretended it cared about the planet. Fast forward to today, and ESG is getting dragged harder than a plastic straw at a climate march.
Critics call it woke investing. Politicians are banning it. Some investors say it doesn’t work. So, is ESG just greenwashed nonsense—or is there still hope?
Let’s separate the facts from the fury.
What Is ESG, Really?
ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance—three non-financial criteria used to evaluate companies:
- Environmental: carbon emissions, waste, resource use, pollution
- Social: labor practices, diversity, human rights, community impact
- Governance: board diversity, transparency, executive pay, corruption risk
The idea: Companies that score well in these areas are more responsible, more resilient, and better long-term bets.
Sounds great, right? So why is everyone so mad?
Why ESG Is Under Fire
Let’s unpack the backlash:
1. Political Weaponization
Some U.S. politicians have framed ESG as “woke capitalism” and launched legal campaigns against asset managers like BlackRock for including ESG in their strategies.
Certain states have even banned public funds from considering ESG factors—arguing that it puts ideology ahead of profits.
2. Greenwashing & Inconsistency
There’s no universal ESG scoring system. One fund’s “sustainable” may include Big Oil or weapons manufacturers. Companies can cherry-pick metrics to look greener than they are.
Example: A coal company with good board diversity could still be ESG-rated by some firms. Make it make sense.
3. Performance Concerns
Critics argue ESG funds underperform. While some years show lower returns, others have shown ESG outperforming during market downturns—especially during COVID.
The issue? ESG isn’t a single strategy—it’s a loose label slapped on everything from ethical investing to “barely different from normal.”
But Wait—Is ESG Actually Failing?
Not so fast. Despite the controversy, ESG is still:
- Growing globally: ESG fund assets may have dipped in the U.S. but are booming in Europe, Asia, and among younger investors
- Pushing transparency: Even flawed ESG metrics force companies to disclose more than they used to
- Fueling innovation: Green tech, clean energy, and diversity-focused funds are getting real money and visibility
- A starting point: ESG may be imperfect—but it’s better than ignoring environmental and social risk altogether
What ESG Does Right
- It gets climate and labor risks on the boardroom table
- It gives investors some tools to steer money toward better behavior
- It helps identify long-term risks (hello, sea-level rise and supply chain fragility)
- It builds pressure for transparency and accountability
What ESG Gets Wrong
- It’s not a magic label—there’s no standardized ESG score
- Funds often include questionable companies (Amazon, Shell, Nestle, etc.)
- It doesn’t inherently mean “ethical” or “climate-positive”
- ESG ratings can be based more on disclosure than actual performance
So Should You Avoid ESG Funds?
No—but don’t blindly trust them either. Here’s what to do:
Read the Fine Print
Check what companies the fund actually holds. If ExxonMobil is listed under “sustainable,” that’s your red flag.
Look for Thematic Funds
Instead of broad ESG funds, try funds that focus on specific issues:
- Clean energy (ICLN, TAN)
- Gender diversity (SHE, WOMN)
- Fossil fuel-free indexes (SPYX, ETHO)
Use Screening Tools
Use platforms like:
- Fossil Free Funds (by As You Sow)
- Morningstar’s ESG Screener
- Your brokerage’s sustainable investing filters
How to Tell If a Company Is Greenwashing ESG
Ask these questions:
- Are their ESG goals tied to actual performance, or just pledges?
- Do they publish annual sustainability reports with real metrics?
- Are their products or services part of the climate solution or the problem?
- Are they improving over time—or just coasting on one good PR campaign?
ESG Isn’t Dead—But It Needs a Reality Check
Think of ESG as training wheels. It won’t get us to net zero on its own. But it has:
- Shifted the conversation
- Triggered more data disclosure
- Pressured companies to do more than maximize profit
Now it needs:
- Better definitions
- More transparency
- Less hype
- More actual impact
Final Thoughts
ESG isn’t a scam—but it’s also not your golden ticket to climate redemption. It’s messy, inconsistent, and often misused. But it’s also one of the only financial frameworks even trying to bring environmental and social values into the investing world.
So before you write it off—or worse, trust it blindly—do your research. ESG is evolving, and we get to shape where it goes next.
Reader Interactions