Not all plastics are created equal, especially when it comes to recycling. While many people assume any item bearing the recycling symbol can be tossed into the curbside bin, the reality is far more complex. In fact, only a small percentage of plastics are truly recyclable through standard municipal programs. Understanding why not all plastics make the cut can help reduce contamination, improve recycling rates, and support a more sustainable lifestyle.
Understanding Plastic Recycling Codes
Every plastic item marked for recycling carries a number from 1 to 7—called a Resin Identification Code (RIC). These numbers refer to the type of plastic used, not its recyclability. Here’s a quick breakdown:
- #1 PET (Polyethylene Terephthalate): Common in water and soda bottles; widely recyclable. Often turned into fibers for clothing or carpet.
- #2 HDPE (High-Density Polyethylene): Found in milk jugs and detergent bottles; accepted curbside in most areas. Frequently recycled into piping, plastic lumber, and more containers.
- #3 PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride): Used in pipes and clear food packaging; rarely accepted due to its chlorine content and difficulty in recycling.
- #4 LDPE (Low-Density Polyethylene): Grocery bags and plastic wraps; usually not recyclable curbside but often accepted at store drop-offs.
- #5 PP (Polypropylene): Yogurt containers, bottle caps, and straws; accepted in some municipalities. Can be recycled into battery cases, brooms, or bins.
- #6 PS (Polystyrene): Foam cups, meat trays, and takeout containers; difficult to recycle and often excluded due to its brittleness and contamination risks.
- #7 Other: Includes mixed or layered plastics, such as acrylic or polycarbonate; rarely recyclable and often landfilled.
Why Some Plastics Aren’t Accepted Curbside
Even if a plastic is technically recyclable, there are several reasons it might not be accepted in curbside bins:
- Material Complexity: Some plastics are made of multiple layers or materials that are hard to separate. For instance, chip bags and juice pouches often have layers of metalized film, paper, and plastic.
- Economic Viability: Recycling certain plastics isn’t cost-effective. If the market value of the recycled material is lower than the cost of processing, facilities may choose not to accept it.
- Contamination: Food-soiled containers, grease, or mixed materials (like a plastic lid on a paper coffee cup) can ruin an entire batch of recyclables.
- Infrastructure Limitations: Each city or town may have different recycling capabilities based on equipment, funding, and contracts with material recovery facilities (MRFs).
The Problem with Wishcycling
Wishcycling—tossing questionable items into the recycling bin in hopes they’ll be recycled—can actually do more harm than good. It’s a well-meaning but misguided effort that leads to several serious consequences:
- Increased Contamination Rates: When non-recyclables are added to the recycling stream, they can contaminate otherwise recyclable materials. This contamination can make it impossible to sort and process the materials properly.
- Rejected Loads: Contaminated loads may be deemed unrecyclable by processing facilities and sent directly to the landfill or incinerator, wasting both resources and effort.
- Higher Processing Costs: Sorting facilities must spend additional time and labor separating trash from recyclable items, driving up operational costs.
- Damaged Equipment: Items like plastic bags, garden hoses, and string lights can jam machinery, causing shutdowns and expensive repairs.
According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), only about 9% of plastic waste is actually recycled. The rest—nearly 91%—ends up in landfills, incinerators, or polluting the environment. By avoiding wishcycling and learning what’s truly recyclable, we can all contribute to improving that number.
How to Know What’s Recyclable
Because local rules vary, always check your municipal recycling guidelines. Look for patterns like the “bottle, jug, tub, and jar” rule. Use resources such as Earth911 or the Recycle Coach app to stay informed. Key tips include:
- Rinse containers to remove food residue. Contamination reduces the quality of recyclables.
- Avoid plastic bags unless specified; they jam sorting machines and usually require special collection.
- Remove caps and lids if your local facility requires it. Some programs now allow caps, but always confirm.
- Avoid small plastic items (like straws, utensils, or pill bottles), which are too small to be sorted properly and often fall through machinery.
Handling Non-Recyclable Plastics
Instead of tossing them in the bin, consider these options:
- Store drop-offs: Many grocery stores accept clean plastic bags, wraps, and film for specialized recycling.
- Mail-in programs: Companies like TerraCycle and Ridwell offer ways to recycle hard-to-process plastics for a fee or through brand partnerships.
- Upcycle at home: Turn containers into storage bins, planters, organizers, or DIY crafts.
- Reduce consumption: Choose reusable containers, avoid single-use items, and look for plastic-free packaging when possible.
Sustainable Alternatives
Minimizing plastic use in the first place is the most effective strategy. Try these swaps:
- Use reusable containers and bags for shopping, storage, and meals.
- Buy in bulk or choose glass, paper, or metal packaging that is more widely recyclable.
- Support brands that offer eco-friendly packaging, like compostable wrappers or refillable containers.
- Advocate for improved recycling programs and better labeling, so consumers know what is actually recyclable.
Final Thoughts
Not all plastics belong in your curbside recycling bin—but knowing which ones do is key to becoming a better recycler. By understanding the resin codes, following local guidelines, and reducing plastic use overall, you can make a meaningful difference. Let’s recycle smarter, not harder. Stay informed, stay sustainable, and help reduce the burden of plastic waste on our planet.
Reader Interactions